ArticlesMediaPolicingLethal Force Ruling Provides Greater Clarity, but Questions RemainAs might have been predicted there has been a high level of controversy around last week's Constitutional Court judgment, dealing with the use of lethal force in effecting arrest, in the case of s v Walter's. In the judgment the court struck down Section 49(2) of the Criminal Procedure Act, a legal provision created by the apartheid government to give… Read More CSVRMay 28, 2002
PublicationsResearchCriminal Justice, PolicingNew Wine from an Old Cask? The South African Police Service and the Process of TransformationThe subsequent paper looks to discuss the South African Police Service (SAPS) and its process of evolution. It delves into many facets of subject, such as the the realities and continuation of police brutality, key dimensions of transformation and repression to crime control. Read More David BruceMay 9, 2002
ArticlesMediaPolicingWhen Is It OK to Kill?Should there be any circumstances where a person is lawfully able to kill another human being? Killing to defend someone is clearly legally justified in South Africa. In 1995 in the case of S v Makwanyane, the Constitutional Court stated that the approach taken in law is to balance 'the rights of the aggressor against the rights of the victim,… Read More CSVRApril 17, 2002
PublicationsResearchCriminal Justice, Policing, Torture and State ViolenceMonitoring Police Violence and Torture in South AfricaWhilst much has been written on human rights violations committed by the police in South Africa, including aspects that have utilized some quantitative data, especially in relation to political detainees, the bulk of these violations perpetrated by the South African Police have not been subject to effective monitoring. The subsequent report analyses facets relating to this, such as the distinction… Read More Piers PigouApril 1, 2002
PublicationsResearchCriminal Justice, PolicingThe Legal Framework on the Use of Lethal Force in Effecting Arrest – A New Section 49?This memorandum had been written in response to the previous impasse over the legislative framework dealing with the use of lethal force for purposes of arrest as provided for in the amendment to Section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act, provided for in Section 7 of the Judicial Matters Amendment Act, 122 of 1998 (henceforward Section 7 of the JMSAA)… Read More David BruceMarch 1, 2002
PublicationsResearchCriminal Justice, PolicingA Duty to Answer Questions? The Police, the Independent Complaints Directorate and the Right to Remain SilentThe following paper focuses on police accountability in the context of police powers. Mechanisms to compel police co-operation in internal investigations, and with the ICD in its investigations are considered within the context of the current Constitutional framework. Read More David Bruce, Kate Savage and Johan De WaalDecember 3, 2001